IVA Advice Online logo
Home › Scotland › Is a Trust Deed a Good Idea? The Pros and Cons
Scotland

Is a Trust Deed a Good Idea? The Pros and Cons

A protected trust deed can write off debt you can't afford and stop creditors chasing you, but it's a formal insolvency with real downsides. Here's how to weigh it up.

Last updated:

Check if you qualify →Free, no-obligation checkWon’t affect your credit score

May not be suitable in all circumstances. Fees apply, read more. Your credit rating may be affected, read more.

This guide covers Scottish law. Debt solutions in England, Wales and Northern Ireland work differently.

The short answer

  • A trust deed suits people in Scotland who owe £5,000 or more and can afford a regular payment but can’t repay in full.
  • Once protected, it’s binding on all your creditors and interest is frozen.
  • Remaining qualifying debt is written off at the end, usually after 48 months.
  • It’s insolvency: it goes on the public register and your credit file for six years.
  • Homeowners may have to release equity.
Please note: IVA Advice Online (My Debt Plan Ltd) does not set up trust deeds, Debt Payment Programmes under DAS or sequestration. If you live in Scotland, we can talk through your options with you and, where appropriate, refer you on to a Scottish specialist partner or a free debt advice service.

Advantages of a trust deed

  • Debt written off: qualifying unsecured debt left after the payment period is written off.
  • One affordable payment: based on your income and reasonable living costs.
  • Creditor action stops: once protected, creditors can’t take diligence, such as wage arrestment, or make you bankrupt for included debts.
  • Interest and charges frozen on included debts.
  • Fixed end date: usually 48 months.
  • Less severe than sequestration for many people, with fewer restrictions.

Disadvantages of a trust deed

  • Credit file: shows for six years, making borrowing hard.
  • Public record: listed on the Register of Insolvencies.
  • Your home: you may be asked to release equity, or the trust deed may be extended.
  • Assets: valuable assets such as a high-value car may need to be dealt with.
  • Not guaranteed: it won’t become protected if a majority of creditors by number, or a third by value, object.
  • If it fails: the trustee can petition for your sequestration.
  • Some jobs are affected, especially in finance and law.
Struggling with debt?

See which debt solutions you could qualify for. Checking your options won’t affect your credit score.

Who a trust deed suits

  • You live in Scotland and owe at least £5,000 in unsecured debt.
  • You have a steady income and some money left after essential costs.
  • You couldn’t repay your debts in full within a reasonable time, even with interest frozen.
  • You want to avoid sequestration, or you’re a homeowner and want more control over your home.

Trust deed vs DAS vs sequestration

If you could repay everything with interest frozen, the Debt Arrangement Scheme avoids insolvency altogether. If you have no spare income and few assets, MAP bankruptcy may be quicker. A trust deed sits between the two. See debt help in Scotland for a comparison table, and how much a trust deed costs.

Common questions

Is a trust deed a good idea?

It can be if you live in Scotland, owe £5,000 or more and can afford a regular payment but couldn't repay your debts in full. It's a formal insolvency, so it affects your credit file and may affect your home.

What are the disadvantages of a trust deed?

It shows on your credit file for six years and on the public Register of Insolvencies, homeowners may need to release equity, and if you don't keep to it you could be made bankrupt.

Is a trust deed better than bankruptcy?

For many people, especially homeowners with a regular income, a trust deed has fewer restrictions than sequestration. Bankruptcy can be quicker for people with no spare income and few assets.

Is a trust deed legit?

Yes. Protected trust deeds are a legal debt solution under the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 2016, run by licensed insolvency practitioners and supervised by the Accountant in Bankruptcy. Check any firm you deal with is properly licensed.

Getting help in Scotland

Free, impartial debt advice in Scotland is available from Money Advice Scotland, Citizens Advice Scotland, StepChange and National Debtline. Official guidance is published by the Accountant in Bankruptcy. You can also get in touch with us to talk through your options.

Want to talk through your options?

Send us an enquiry.

See if you qualify →