Quick answer: Debt consolidation is usually a good idea if it lowers your total cost, the new payment is easily affordable and you stop using the old credit. It's usually a bad idea if you're already behind, would extend short-term debt over many years, or would secure unsecured debts on your home.
Key facts
- Consolidation is usually a good idea when it lowers your total cost and the payment is easily affordable.
- It’s usually a bad idea if you’re already behind or would keep using the old credit.
- It affects your credit score through a hard search and new account, then depends on whether you pay on time.
- If you can’t afford your debts, look at debt solutions rather than new borrowing.
A quick checklist
Debt consolidation is more likely to help if you can answer yes to all of these:
- I’m up to date with all my payments.
- The new deal costs less in total than my current debts.
- I can afford the new payment and my priority bills every month.
- I’ll close or stop using the credit I clear.
- I’m not putting unsecured debt onto my home.
If you answered no to any of them, slow down and look at the alternatives below.
Advantages of debt consolidation
- One payment and one date to remember.
- Can reduce the interest you pay.
- A fixed end date with a loan.
- Can help your credit score over time if you pay on time.
Disadvantages of debt consolidation
- You still owe the full amount.
- Longer terms can cost more overall.
- Fees and early settlement charges can wipe out the saving.
- It can make it easier to build up new debt on top.
- Secured options put your home at risk.
See which debt solutions you could qualify for. Checking your options won’t affect your credit score.
Does debt consolidation affect your credit score?
In the short term, a full credit application leaves a hard search, and opening a new account can lower your score slightly. In the longer term, paying the new loan on time and reducing card balances can improve it. Consolidating through a debt management plan is different: creditors may mark your accounts as in an arrangement or default them, which shows on your file. An IVA also affects your credit rating, usually for six years.
Is debt consolidation better than an IVA?
They do different jobs. Consolidation reorganises debt you can afford to repay. An IVA is for when you can’t afford to repay it all. See debt consolidation vs an IVA and IVA pros and cons.
Common questions
Is consolidating debt a good idea?
It's a good idea when it lowers your overall cost, the payment is comfortably affordable and you stop using the cleared credit. It's usually not a good idea if you are already behind.
How does debt consolidation affect your credit score?
A hard search and new account can lower your score for a short time. Paying on time and lowering card balances can improve it over months.
What is the downside of debt consolidation?
You still owe the full amount, a long term can cost more in total, and it can make it easy to run up new debt on the cards you have cleared.
Is it better to consolidate debt or pay it off?
If you can afford to pay your debts off as they are, targeting the most expensive debt first is often cheapest. Consolidation helps if it gets you a lower rate or a payment you can manage more easily.
Getting help
Free, impartial help with debt and borrowing decisions is available from MoneyHelper, StepChange and National Debtline. You can check whether a lender or broker is authorised on the FCA register. If you want to talk through whether a debt solution such as an IVA could be suitable, you can also get in touch with us.
Sources
Checked November 2026. Rules and figures can change, so check the latest guidance before you act.