IVA Advice Online logo
Home › Debt Consolidation › Secured Loan vs Remortgage: Which Is Better?
Debt Consolidation

Secured Loan vs Remortgage: Which Is Better?

If you want to borrow against your home, you can usually either take a secured loan on top of your mortgage or remortgage for a larger amount. The cheaper option depends on your current deal.

Last updated:

Check if you qualify →Free, no-obligation checkWon’t affect your credit score

May not be suitable in all circumstances. Fees apply, read more. Your credit rating may be affected, read more.

The formal debt solutions mentioned here (IVAs, DROs and bankruptcy) follow the rules for England and Wales. If you live in Scotland, different solutions apply.

Quick answer: A secured loan sits alongside your current mortgage, while a remortgage replaces it with a bigger one. A secured loan can be cheaper if remortgaging would trigger early repayment charges. Otherwise a remortgage usually has a lower rate. Compare the total cost of each, including fees.

Key facts

  • A secured loan sits alongside your mortgage. A remortgage replaces it with a bigger one.
  • A secured loan can avoid early repayment charges on a low-rate mortgage deal.
  • Remortgage rates are usually lower, but you borrow the whole amount at the new rate.
  • Compare the total cost of each, including fees and charges.
  • Both put your home at risk if you can’t repay.
Please note: IVA Advice Online (My Debt Plan Ltd) does not provide, arrange or recommend loans or other credit. This guide explains how borrowing to consolidate debt works so you can decide for yourself. If you’re struggling to keep up with your debts, we can talk you through other options.

How they differ

Secured loanRemortgage
Your current mortgageStays as it isPaid off and replaced
Early repayment chargesUsually avoidedMay apply if you’re mid-deal
RateUsually higher than mortgage ratesUsually lower
PaymentsTwo monthly paymentsOne
FeesBroker and lender fees are commonArrangement, valuation and legal fees may apply
ApprovalSome lenders accept weaker creditMain lenders can be stricter

When a secured loan might be cheaper

  • You’re locked into a low-rate mortgage with big early repayment charges.
  • You only need a relatively small amount compared with your mortgage.
  • Your main lender won’t lend more.

When remortgaging might be cheaper

  • Your current deal is ending, so there are no early repayment charges.
  • You’re on your lender’s standard variable rate.
  • Remortgage rates are lower than secured loan rates for the amount you need.
Struggling with debt?

See which debt solutions you could qualify for. Checking your options won’t affect your credit score.

Don’t forget the total cost

Whichever you choose, spreading short-term debts over a long mortgage-style term can mean paying much more interest overall. Ask for the total amount repayable for each option. For more detail, see second charge mortgages and remortgaging to pay off debt.

If you’re borrowing because you’re struggling

If you need to borrow against your home to keep up with debts, look at whether a debt management plan or an IVA would deal with those debts without extra secured borrowing.

Common questions

Is a secured loan cheaper than remortgaging?

It depends. A secured loan can be cheaper if remortgaging would mean large early repayment charges. Otherwise a remortgage usually has a lower rate.

Can I get a secured loan instead of remortgaging?

Yes. A secured loan, also called a second charge mortgage, lets you borrow against your home without changing your existing mortgage.

Which is easier to get, a secured loan or a remortgage?

Some secured loan lenders accept weaker credit than mainstream mortgage lenders, but both involve affordability checks.

Do I pay two mortgages with a secured loan?

Yes. You keep paying your main mortgage and make a separate payment for the secured loan.

Getting help

Free, impartial help with debt and borrowing decisions is available from MoneyHelper, StepChange and National Debtline. You can check whether a lender or broker is authorised on the FCA register. If you want to talk through whether a debt solution such as an IVA could be suitable, you can also get in touch with us.

Sources

Checked November 2026. Rules and figures can change, so check the latest guidance before you act.

Want to talk through your options?

Send us an enquiry.

See if you qualify →